Muscle Injury and Healing

by Nerissa Freeman, CMT, SPT

from The Kiai Echo - Summer 1997

Martial artists suffer injuries of all kinds and jujitsuka are no exception. Included among those injuries are muscle "pulls" (strains) and muscle soreness following heavy workouts. This article will attempt to answer some questions about the science behind muscle strains and soreness and what we can do to prevent them. What are the microscopic mechanisms behind these injuries? What are the healing processes that take place at a cellular level? How can we prevent these injuries?

Structure of Skeletal Muscle

A muscle can do only one thing: contract. Skeletal muscle is especially designed to move the skeleton through space. We rely on skeletal muscle to move our fingers in order to write, to move our whole body in order to throw ogoshi, and to remain upright while sitting quietly in meditation.

A muscle is made up of thousands of muscle fibers. Muscle fibers are composed of microscopic proteins and other molecules that allow a muscle to contract. These fibers are what are injured and then repaired in a muscle strain. In addition, another kind of tissue is present in muscle which does not contract but helps support the overall structure of the muscle. This is connective tissue and, as the most abundant of the primary tissues of the human body, is present in many forms and has a wide variety of functions. As we will see later, damaged connective tissue has been implicated as one of the causes of delayed onset muscle soreness.

Muscle fibers make up the bulk of a muscle. In order to attach to bones, they often blend into a different type of tissue which makes up tendons. Tendons generally cross a joint and help facilitate movement. For example, the quadriceps muscle on the front of the thigh has a large tendon that attaches to the shin bone. When this muscle contracts, the knee is straightened. A tendon is different from a ligament, which generally attaches from one bone to another bone and mainly serves to stabilize a joint. For example, the knee joint has several strong ligaments that help hold it together but they do not cause movement in and of themselves. Later, we will see how the junction between a muscle and its tendon is a frequent site of damage.

Types of Contractions

Muscle contractions are generally classified into three different types. This is important to understand since one particular type of contraction tends to be responsible for most injuries.

Concentric contractions occur when a muscle shortens in order to exert force. For example, the biceps muscle does a concentric contraction in order to do an arm curl.

Isometric contractions are when the muscle exerts a force but there is no movement in the limb. An example would be carrying a bag of groceries; the arm muscles are contracting in order to hold the bag, but the arm itself is not moving.

Eccentric contractions are the contractions we rely on the most. These are contractions that occur in a muscle while it is lengthening. For example, as a person lowers the curl bar in a biceps curl, the biceps are performing eccentric contractions in order to slow the descent of the bar. The muscle is getting longer, but it is still exerting force.

Muscle Strain and Regeneration

It is widely accepted that muscle strain injuries occur more frequently with eccentric muscle contractions. This may be due to the significantly greater force produced by these contractions as compared to concentric or isometric contractions (9).

Surprisingly, the precise physiologic mechanisms that characterize muscle strains have not been extensively studied (11, 17). It is thought that strain injuries most frequently happen near the muscle-tendon junction and that the muscle fibers themselves are partially torn (2, 11, 17). Tears can occur from a single, violent excessive force (acute strain) or from prolonged overuse or one episode of over activity (chronic strain) (2).

Skeletal muscle has an impressive ability to regenerate itself, which it does on a daily basis as well as in response to injury. When muscle fibers are damaged, several steps occur before regeneration can take place (12). First, the dead muscle fibers are removed by special cells called macrophages. These cells migrate to the damaged area through the bloodstream, so if the blood supply to the injured area has been significantly damaged, regeneration cannot take place until new blood vessels penetrate the area (7). Regeneration of single muscle fibers or entire muscles can then occur only when certain cells are activated. These special cells are called satellite cells (4, 18). When a muscle is damaged, these cells are activated within 18 hours of the injury (18). It also appears that these cells are able to migrate, and may move from healthy areas of the muscle to the injured area in response to a chemical stimulus (4, 18). These cells then fuse together to form myoblasts, which in turn fuse to form myotubes (3, 18). The myotubes then mature to form muscle fibers (3, 18). This may sound very straightforward, but many factors determine the success of the regeneration process. The extent of injury to nerves and blood vessels has a clear effect on how quickly the damaged area can obtain nutrients and be under normal control by the nervous system. Furthermore, all muscle is not the same. Not only can both the final shapes and functions of muscles be different, but the molecules within the muscle may not be alike (6). Finally, the properties of muscle may be different than they were before injury. Fewer numbers of muscle fibers are present, with a subsequent reduction in muscle mass (18). Regenerated muscle, however, does regain normal contraction and relaxation times (13, 18). This essentially means that the repaired muscle will not be as "strong" as it was before it was injured, although it may be able to contract just as quickly.

Muscle may also heal with scar tissue instead of with new muscle fibers (18). Scar tissue is a normal part of the healing process for many injuries, but may obstruct further muscle regeneration if present in muscle tissue (18). It also interferes with the normal contraction and elasticity of skeletal muscle. In addition, it is also composed of a different type of tissue than muscle and grows much more quickly (18).

Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness

Most jujitsuka have experienced muscle soreness 24 to 72 hours after a particularly hard workout (8, 10). This is called delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS), and is different from fatigue in that there is actual damage to the muscle (11, 14). The soreness is not caused by a build up of lactic acid (1, 8, 14). This is a commonly held misconception that has been disproved by many studies (1, 8, 14, 16). There is no evidence that lactic acid build-up causes pain associated with DOMS, and in fact, studies have shown that it takes only about an hour of rest to completely remove lactic acid from the blood and skeletal muscle (7, 9). There are several schools of thought as to what actually causes the pain associated with DOMS. Some feel that damage to the muscle fibers or connective tissue is the primary cause of pain, although general inflammation and the increased release of certain enzymes has also been implicated (1, 8, 11, 14, 16). Although further research is needed to clarify the exact mechanisms of DOMS, it is clear that the pain is due to damage to some part of the muscle itself.

This damage to muscle fibers or connective tissue would be repaired in the same way as the more severe damage found in muscle strain. Regeneration of muscle fibers would occur and the repair of connective tissue would proceed according to its own repair processes.

Prevention and Treatment of Muscle Injuries

A discussion of the processes of muscle injury and healing would not be complete without some mention of the methods used to prevent and treat these injuries. Of course, jujitsuka and all athletes should contact their primary health care provider in the case of severe injury. Most jujitsuka are aware of and use various Chinese liniments and medicines in order to treat musculoskeletal problems, and their use will not be discussed here. Readers should consult a local acupuncturist or Doctor of Traditional Chinese Medicine for more information. The application of ice is known to decrease inflammation and pain, and is often helpful in the treatment of DOMS as well as muscle strains (8). Controlled exercise has also been shown to promote orderly healing of muscle after a strain injury, particularly after a period of rest (5). Light concentric exercise performed 24 hours after heavy eccentric exercise has also been studied and appears to reduce the effects of DOMS (1, 8). Medications are also widely used in order to treat pain caused by DOMS or muscle strains, and the reader is encouraged to consult a physician or pharmacist for recommendations.

Improper warm-up before exercise, fatigue, previous injury, and other environmental conditions have been shown to increase the chance for injury, so reducing these factors is important for prevention (3). Gradually training muscles specifically in eccentric contractions is helpful in reducing muscle strain injuries and DOMS. One study has found that a single bout of eccentric exercise had a protective effect which decreased muscle soreness in subsequent episodes of eccentric exercise (7). A warm-up or conditioning period has been shown to alter the properties of muscle and make it less susceptible to injury (10). The warm-up period should consist of a mild to moderate level of activity that should prepare the muscles for more intense work. This does not necessarily include heavy stretching, which is probably best done after intense exercise as a cool-down. For jujitsuka, this means gradually introducing muscles to more activity in any one training session and over several sessions. Experienced jujitsuka and judoka can begin with some Nage Te after general warm-ups, making sure to do the throws more slowly. This will prepare the body for more dynamic or complicated techniques such as speed uchi kome or techniques from Oku No Te.

It is hoped that this discussion has cleared up some misconceptions about muscle injuries as well as offered some helpful suggestions for jujitsuka to maximize their training time and minimize injuries. After all, most of us would rather spend our time on the mat that off of it with an injury!

Note: Special thanks to Linda Wanek, PhD, PT, for her help in preparing this article.

References

  1. Albert M. Eccentric Muscle Training in Sports and Orthopaedics. New York: Churchill LIvingstone, 1991.
  2. Arrington ED, Miller MD. Skeletal Muscle Injuries. Orthop Clinics North America. 26(3):411-422, 1995.
  3. Best TM. Muscle-Tendon Injuries in Young Athletes. Clinics in Sports Med. 14(3):669-686, 1995.
  4. Bischoff R. Interaction Between Satellite Cells and Skeletal Muscle Fibers. Development. 109:943-952, 1990.
  5. Buckwalter JA. Effects of Early Motion on Healing of Musculoskeletal Tissues. Hand Clinics. 12(1):13-24, 1996.
  6. Caplan A, Carlson B, Faulkner J, Fischman D, Garrett, Jr. W. Skeletal Muscle. In: Injury and Repair of the Musculoskeletal Soft Tissues. eds. Savio L-Y. Woo and JA Buckwalter. Park Ridge, IL: American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 1988.
  7. Carlson BM, Faulkner JA. The Regeneration of Skeletal Muscle Fibers Following Injury: A Review. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 15(3):187-198, 1983.
  8. Cleak MJ, Eston RG. Delayed Onset Muscle Soreness: Mechanisms and Management. J Sports Sciences. 10:325-341, 1992.
  9. Fox EL, Robinson S, Wiegman D. Metabolic Energy Sources During Continuous and Interval Running. J Appl Physiol. 27:174, 1969.
  10. Garrett, Jr. WE. Muscle Strain Injuries: Clinical and Basic Aspects. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 22(4):436-443, 1990.
  11. Garrett, Jr. W, Tidball J. Myotendinous Junction: Structure, Function, and Failure. In: Injury and Repair of the Musculoskeltal Soft Tissues. eds. Savio L-Y. Woo and JA Buckwalter. Park Ridge, IL: American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons, 1988.
  12. Grounds MD. Towards Understanding Skeletal Muscle Regeneration. Path Res Pract. 187:1-22, 1991.
  13. Lieber RL. Skeletal Muscle Structure and Function: Implications for Rehabilitation and Sports Medicine. Philadelphia: Williams & Wilkins, 1992.
  14. Jones DA, Round JM. Skeletal Muscle in Health and Disease: A Textbook of Muscle Physiology. New York: Manchester University Press, 1990.
  15. Karlsson J, Satlin B. Oxygen Deficits and Muscle Metabolites in Intermittent Exercise. Acta Physiol Scand. 82:115, 1971.
  16. Kisner C, Colby LA. Therapeutic Exercise: Foundations and Techniques. 2nd ed. Philadelphia: F. A. Davis, 1985.
  17. Russell B, Dix Dj, Haller DL, Jacobs-El J. Repair of Injured Skeletal Muscle: A Molecular Approach. Med Sci Sports Exerc. 24(2):189-196, 1992.
  18. Wanek L. Skeletal Muscle Development, Injury, and Regeneration. PT 701: Musculoskeletal Pathokinesiology I, Spring, 1997. Course Syllabus. San Francisco:UCSF/SFSU Graduate Program in Physical Therapy, 1997.

Nerissa Freeman is a shodan in the AJJF and will receive a Master of Physical Therapy degree from the University of California, San Francisco/San Francisco State University on December 31, 1997. This program involves the study of gross anatomy and neuromusculoskeletal function as it relates to rehabilitation. She has also completed the AJJF massage program.

Linda Wanek, PhD (who helped edit the article), is a member of the faculty in Nerissa's physical therapy program who has a special interest in research on skeletal muscle injury and healing.


Questions and Answers

Dec. 8, 2000

What by product of anaerobic metabolism does the heart use for energy?
The heart has striated muscle fibers much like skeletal muscle but it is unique in that it relies almost totally on the energy released from aerobic reactions. However, it can also use the energy released from the oxidation of lactate during strenuous exercise.

What type of muscle contraction causes the highest degree of delayed onset muscle soreness.
The answer is in the above article. Eccentric muscle contractions are most likely to lead to delayed onset muscle soreness.

This information can be found in any exercise physiology text. You can reference Exercise Physiology: Energy, Nutrition and Human Performance, by W.D. McArdle, F.I. Katch, and V.L. Katch.

Thanks for the questions!
Nerissa Freeman, CMT, SPT, MPT. December 8, 2001.


* To The Kiai Echo Articles Page.

* To AJJF Home Page.


Maintained by: ajjf-webmaster@ajjf.org, we welcome comments.
Last modified: 01/12/23

Copyright © 1997, 2000 American Judo & Jujitsu Federation.
All rights reserved.